Paolo Colombo from ANSYS talks safety, simulation, and the future of Urban Air Mobility

During the conversation, Colombo touched on safety, technology, emissions, noise, and other concerns as the UAM industry readies for takeoff.

Earlier this year, Honeywell and Volocopter have signed an agreement to jointly test and develop new navigation and automatic landing systems for Volocopter’s vertical takeoff and landing aircraft (VTOL) (see above) as the emerging era of urban air mobility moves closer to fruition.
Earlier this year, Honeywell and Volocopter have signed an agreement to jointly test and develop new navigation and automatic landing systems for Volocopter’s vertical takeoff and landing aircraft (VTOL) (see above) as the emerging era of urban air mobility moves closer to fruition.
Editor’s note: Myriad companies across the world have embraced urban air mobility (UAM), which they envision will move people around swelling megacities and crowded urban environments. With the prospect of people flying in autonomous or remotely-piloted aircraft, safety is of paramount importance. Intelligent Aerospace associate editor Jamie Whitney recently had a conversation with Paolo Colombo, who is the Aerospace and Defense Global Industry Director at ANSYS. During the conversation, Colombo touched on safety, technology, emissions, noise, and other concerns as the UAM industry readies for takeoff.

NASHUA N.H. –  Before anything takes flight in a commercial setting, urban air mobility (UAM) designers need to ensure the vehicle is airworthy and is safe for both occupants in and people outside the aircraft. In years past, that meant a brave test pilot would jump in the cockpit and put his or her faith in the project engineers and manufacturers. With UAM, that is unnecessary as these aircraft will fly sans a cockpit, much less a pilot in the vehicle. In addition, simulation software has gotten sophisticated enough that designers can run their aircraft through an incredible number of scenarios and flight conditions and have a very strong degree of surety before a real motor is even attached to an aircraft.Bell Helicopter revealed the configuration and full-scale vertical-takeoff-and-landing (VTOL) air taxi vehicle during CES 2019. The air taxi, named Bell Nexus, is powered by a hybrid-electric propulsion system and features Bell’s powered lift concept incorporating six tilting ducted fans that are designed to safely and efficiently redefine air travel.Bell Helicopter revealed the configuration and full-scale vertical-takeoff-and-landing (VTOL) air taxi vehicle during CES 2019. The air taxi, named Bell Nexus, is powered by a hybrid-electric propulsion system and features Bell’s powered lift concept incorporating six tilting ducted fans that are designed to safely and efficiently redefine air travel.

"This is bringing us the capability to analyze functional safety in a unique environment," ANSYS' Colombo said. "We acquired a number of companies recently in order to create the platform that will be very important for urban air mobility - specifically for urban air mobility...We are creating more robustness with full automation. A customer had something like a 55% decrease in effort and time to perform functional safety analysis."

Of course, even if the UAM aircraft has demonstrated safety in tests and simulations, regulators like the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) or the European Union Aviation Safety Agency (EASA) are still going have a close eye on this young sector as it comes into fruition.

Related: EHang completes AAV demo flight with a passenger in Changchun, China

"This is a long discussion that the companies are having with FAA, and other stakeholders like EASA," said Colombo. "We have a huge number of new technologies that are coming so fast. This is really changing the way the industry should think. If you don’t use these technologies, even if you are one of the leading companies in the industry, you risk falling behind."

Colombo continued, "We don’t have 50 years or more of experience using this technology - automated systems and sensors. We have more than 30 antennas on a fuselage. You have to find a way to test it to verify it and certify it. That’s a huge, huge challenge. Nobody has a clear idea of how to do that. There are new ways everyone is exploring. The FAA and EASA are asking for more and more functional safety analysis as they don’t have a clear path for certification of these systems. They are asking companies to prove that they have done failure analysis and mitigated that risk as much as possible. They decide if this company can move on or not. This is where we are with this new technology."

Technology, though, has a way to go until it can match human perception of objects moving in three dimensions as systems decide whether an airborne object is a risk to the aircraft.  

"Electronic situation awareness - it’s very important to understand what is really happening," Colombo said. "Sensors can be fooled by stupid things. Just imagine the glare of the Sun. Imagine the classical plastic bag (blowing by). You recognize it, and you go on. Sensors do not have this kind of human intelligence. They see an obstacle coming in a very crazy pattern and they can freeze and not know what to do. They can react, creating a very dangerous situation that, for a human person, is basically nothing. This is what we need to be sure of. In order to be sure of that, it needs to be always working properly in an infinite situation an urban environment. We need to test these systems forever, basically."

Related: Honeywell and Volocopter agree to jointly test and develop urban air mobility systems

In addition to ensuring safety, noise mitigation will also be an issue. While UAM aircraft designs are nearly all electric vertical takeoff and landing (eVTOL), the large (or high number of) propellers needed to transport people and their belongings results in quite a bit of noise. If hundreds of aircraft are crisscrossing Tokyo, Rome, Karachi, Los Angeles, or any other crowded major city, the already noisy landscape will have an additional cacophony of buzzing aircraft. Silent eVTOL flight isn't in the offing, but designers can utilize technology to make their UAM aircraft as quiet as possible.

"For instance, if you take an aircraft with propellers, actually a big part of the noise is coming from the tip of the propeller because they can get it so fast that they can approach a supersonic speed and this is creating a lot of noise," related Colombo. "So maybe you can have a smaller propeller adding more energy and so you know you need to design your aircraft in a very different way to have distributed propulsion that is safer because you have more motors, but it is always quieter, so the way you shape your propeller could be part of the noise reduction."

He continued, "We can work on perceived noise so it is not something absolute, but we can simulate the noises perceived by people and so identify which frequencies are the ones that are really giving you that bad feeling. I would then work on the entire structure in order to change these frequencies and mitigate or even avoid them. So, the noise that you have is something that is perceived as something you can (tolerate in) your life. So, it is very interesting and very complex environment, and it is not something you do only for the new vision (systems) because even if you think about the commercial transportation and you look at the goals that both the FAA in the United States and the EASA in Europe are giving to the industry. Together we have fuel-consumption reduction when you think about creating more environmentally-friendly aircraft. That, by the way, is one of the key initiatives of the industry."

Colombo said that if the noise with UAM can be tackled to the point where the perceived noise experienced by people on the ground is acceptable enough, it may open an otherwise unused block of time to keep business running.

EHang performed its first UAM passenger-carrying AAV demonstration flight at the 2019 Northeast Asia Expo, held from August 23-27 in the capital city of China's Jilin province, Changchun.EHang performed its first UAM passenger-carrying AAV demonstration flight at the 2019 Northeast Asia Expo, held from August 23-27 in the capital city of China's Jilin province, Changchun."If you live close to a big airport you probably know that at a certain time, in the evening, nothing is landing or taking off anymore," said Colombo. "So, the airport will be closed during the night and the main reason for that it is actually noise. So if you have a new kind of aircraft that is very quiet as we are expecting from electric vehicles, well, maybe you can use these (time) slots to take off and land during the night and because our airports are very congested and this could be actually very, very, very, important in a world where we are thinking about a big rise in air transportation politically."

While megacities in China seem a natural fit for UAM, they are currently being built up using construction engineered with 21st century standards and road systems made to accommodate an increasingly mobile population. While Zunyi and Guiyang in China are seeing double-digit population growth annually, cities that have foundations in antiquity and wish to hold onto that history, like Rome, may not be experiencing huge population growth, but they are under the burden of incredibly congested roadways and could alleviate that with UAM.

Related: Urban Air Mobility already has 200 eVTOL designs

Colombo, who himself resides in Italy, spoke about the unique challenges that are faced in Rome, which, while not a "megacity," has its roads choked with cars, bikes, and scooters.

"Why is Rome so congested? The answer is, Rome was designed 3,000 years ago," informed Colombo. "You have very narrow roads. You cannot just blow everything (up) and rebuild it. Every building in Rome is at least a 1,000 years (old). So, you build a very nice underground (train system), but if you dig five minutes, you hit (an ancient Roman site). You can use 3-D space and look to the sky as a possible mobility area. It’s very interesting."

As humankind continues its worldwide migration from rural areas to cities, urban air mobility will likely play a growing role in moving those people around. To do so, UAM manufactures have the difficult task of developing a whole new system of moving small number of people or loads of cargo around a three-dimensional environment with numerous other aircraft. With smart design, tested technology, and oversight from regulators, we may be on the cusp on the UAM revolution, and it looks not only to be exciting, but safe as well.

About Paolo Colombo: Colombo was born in Italy in 1970 and joined the Air Force as student pilot in 1992 and, though his career took a different path, he is still regularly flying. From 1999 his passion for advanced technologies brought him to work with companies' managers and executives on emerging technologies in product engineering, rapid prototyping, additive manufacturing and engineering simulation. He joined ANSYS in 2010.


More in Unmanned